5 Common Mistakes Beginners Make in Amazon FBA Arbitrage (and How to Avoid Them)

Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) is one of the most accessible ways to start an online business, and the arbitrage model, whether retail or online arbitrage, allows sellers to capitalise on price differences across different marketplaces. However, many beginners make avoidable mistakes that cost them money, time, and even their Amazon seller account.

To help you build a sustainable, scalable business, here are five common mistakes new sellers make and how to avoid them.

1. Not Properly Analysing Product Demand and Competition

Why This is a Problem

Many new sellers jump on a product simply because they see a low buy price and a high selling price on Amazon. However, failing to analyse actual sales demand and competition can lead to slow-moving inventory, lost capital, and storage fees.

How to Avoid It

• Use Keepa or SellerAmp: Tools like Keepa help you analyse sales rank trends, Buy Box pricing, and product history to make informed purchasing decisions.
• Check Sales Rank: A low Best Sellers Rank (BSR) indicates high demand, but it’s essential to check the product's historical rank, not just its current snapshot.
• Assess Competition: Avoid products flooded with FBA sellers unless you have a clear competitive advantage. Look for listings where you can compete effectively on price, stock availability, or value-add (e.g., bundling).

2. Ignoring Amazon’s Selling Restrictions and IP Complaints

Why This is a Problem

Amazon has strict brand restrictions, category approvals, and intellectual property (IP) rights. Selling a restricted or flagged product without approval can result in account suspensions, removal of listings, or even legal action from brands.

How to Avoid It

• Check Restrictions Before Buying: Use Amazon Seller Central or tools like BuyBotPro to see if you’re gated (restricted) from selling a product.
• Avoid High-Risk Brands: Some brands frequently file IP complaints, making them risky to sell. Analyse Keepa chart historyhistory before sourcing.
• Get Ungated in Profitable Categories: Many sellers start in ungated categories like books, home goods, and toys, but getting ungated in categories like grocery, health, and beauty can open new opportunities.

3. Poor Pricing Strategy and Repricing Mistakes

Why This is a Problem

Many beginners either price their products too high and get no sales or race to the bottom by undercutting competitors, hurting profitability. Without a solid pricing strategy, sellers can lose money, miss out on Buy Box rotations, or trigger unwanted Amazon alerts.

How to Avoid It

• Use Automated Repricers: Software like Profit Protector Pro helps adjust pricing based on market conditions while protecting your margins.
• Monitor Buy Box Trends: The Buy Box price fluctuates based on demand, seller competition, and stock levels. Understanding when and how the Buy Box rotates can help you maximize profit.
• Avoid Panic Price Drops: Just because competitors lower their prices doesn’t mean you should. Check if their stock levels are low—if they sell out, the price may rebound.

4. Not Factoring in All Fees and Hidden Costs

Why This is a Problem

Beginners often underestimate Amazon fees, storage costs, and prep expenses, leading to lower-than-expected profits or even losses.

How to Avoid It

• Use an FBA Profit Calculator: Ensure consistency across your profit calculations by using software like Sellerboard or Seller Toolkit, which provide clear breakdowns of all fees.
• Account for Prep Costs: If using a prep center, factor in their per-unit fees for labeling, bundling, and shipping.
• Watch Out for Storage Fees: Long-term storage fees can eat into your profits. Price competitively and avoid overstocking slow-moving items.

5. Poor Inventory Management and Cash Flow Planning

Why This is a Problem

Many beginners either buy too much inventory too soon or don’t reinvest profits strategically, causing cash flow problems.

How to Avoid It

• Start with a Budget: Don’t invest all your capital upfront. Test different product categories and analyse sell-through rates before scaling.
• Track Inventory Regularly: Use tools like Sellerboard or Seller Toolkit to monitor sales trends and avoid stockouts or excess stock that could lead to slow sales.
• Reinvest Wisely: Profitable sellers reinvest a portion of earnings into new stock while setting aside funds for business expenses (software, subscriptions, taxes).

Conclusion: Learn from These Mistakes and Build a Profitable FBA Business

Amazon FBA is an incredible business model, but mistakes can quickly erode profits or even jeopardise your seller account. By focusing on data-driven sourcing, Amazon compliance, smart pricing strategies, and proper inventory management, you can avoid these common pitfalls and build a successful, scalable business.

Join the FBA Navigators Community

Want to connect with experienced sellers, access exclusive resources, and get expert support as you grow your FBA business? Join the FBA Navigators community today and take your Amazon business to the next level!